With over 450 years of history, discovering an unexplored corner in the nation’s oldest city might seem unlikely. Yet, St. Augustine is still home to several hidden gems. While the most famous attractions are must-visits for every tourist, numerous local favorites offer unique and unparalleled experiences. To enhance your next trip to Northeast Florida, we’ve curated a list of the best places and activities that veer off the conventional tourist trail.
1. Aviles Street
As the oldest city in the nation, St. Augustine is replete with historic sites and attractions that span centuries, inviting visitors to explore and uncover their hidden gems. Aviles Street stands out among these treasures. Recognized as the oldest public street in the United States, its cobblestone path is documented on maps from the early 1570s. Following renovations in 2010, which introduced wider sidewalks, more benches, and enhanced landscaping, Aviles Street has become one of St. Augustine’s most vibrant thoroughfares. It’s a hub for fine dining, historic museums, and unique locally owned boutiques.
Art and Galleries
Taking a stroll down Aviles Street is an experience in itself, but the area offers much more to see and do. For art lovers, Aviles Street is particularly appealing, regarded by many as St. Augustine’s premier art district. Visitors can explore numerous galleries, such as the Plum Gallery, Aviles Street Gallery, and Georgia Nick Gallery, among others. The street also boasts an eclectic mix of restaurants serving a wide array of cuisines, from Greek and Cuban to Polish, Italian, and American. Additionally, a variety of shops present unique finds perfect for a keepsake of your St. Augustine visit, including glasswork, local art, leather goods, custom jewelry, and vintage prints and maps.
2. CAFÉ ALCAZAR
Inside the Lightner Museum: A Culinary Gem in St. Augustine
While exploring St. Augustine and after visiting its most celebrated attractions, make sure to wander off the well-trodden path to uncover Café Alcazar, a hidden treasure offering an unparalleled dining experience. Nestled within the Lightner Museum, originally the site of the world’s largest indoor swimming pool, Café Alcazar provides a touch of elegance and indulgence seven days a week for lunch, and a special dinner service once a month.
Location
Located in the pool’s former deep end, this historic establishment stands as one of St. Augustine’s most remarkable restaurants. Its lavish atmosphere invites diners in search of an exceptional culinary journey. With the dining area set on the ground floor, encircled by three tiers of balconies, guests are transported to an earlier epoch. The menu delights with selections such as escargot, sesame shrimp skewers, crepes, soups, salads, and sandwiches, promising a meal to remember. The experience is perfected with a slice of the light and zesty key lime pie, a signature dessert of St. Augustine. Live music enhances the ambiance daily, featuring a classical guitarist from Monday to Wednesday, and a classical pianist from Thursday to Sunday, adding to the café’s enchanting appeal.
3. Feed the Koi
In the courtyard of the Lightner Museum, there’s a charming scene often overlooked: a lady on a footbridge feeding koi fish in a pond, enveloped by lush greenery. This hidden treasure within the museum’s courtyard captures the hearts of St. Augustine visitors of all ages. A tranquil atrium spot, the koi pond is graced with beautiful foliage and a quaint footbridge crossing over it, where large koi in shades of white, orange, and yellow glide gracefully. These shimmering freshwater fish, ranging from vivid gold to albino white, show as much curiosity towards you as you do towards them, eagerly approaching the pond’s edge for a closer look.
Tranquil Oasis
Familiar with being fed by visitors, the koi exhibit bursts of excitement at the prospect of treats, a sight that, while seemingly chaotic, is merely their way of enjoying a snack. The footbridge offers a serene getaway from the museum’s busier sections, inviting you to pause and immerse yourself in the tranquility of the environment. It’s an ideal spot for capturing memorable vacation photos against the picturesque backdrop of the koi pond and footbridge. Remember to bring quarters for the fish food machines located nearby, adding to the experience of interacting with these friendly St. Augustine residents.
4. Craft Cocktails
The ancient city of St. Augustine is not only renowned for its deep historical roots but also for its rich heritage in wine, spirits, and cocktail innovations. It’s said that Pedro Menendez, the founder of the city in 1565, brought a brewmaster from Spain, highlighting the city’s long-standing affinity for quality beverages. Today, St. Augustine caters to all tastes, offering an extensive selection of beer, wine, and handcrafted cocktails. It’s rapidly gaining recognition as a premier destination for craft cocktails in Florida.
St. Augustine Distillery
At the heart of this burgeoning scene is the St. Augustine Distillery. This artisanal, small-batch distillery produces a variety of spirits, including rum, vodka, gin, and bourbon, inviting visitors not only to savor exceptional craft cocktails but also to delve into the intricacies of spirit production. A distillery tour offers an intriguing glimpse into its history, the distillation process, the impact of Prohibition in Florida, and the secrets of barrel aging. Beyond the distillery, St. Augustine is alive with bars and pubs that serve an imaginative array of craft cocktails, from the innovative and quirky to the rich and stylish. Notable spots include Ice Plant and Odd Birds, known for their emphasis on fresh, quality ingredients and premium spirits, as well as Dos Gatos, The Social Lounge, Prohibition Kitchen, Cellar 6, and Ancient City Brewing Taproom, among others.
5. Tiffany Stained Glass Windows
The interior of the Flagler Tiffany window in St. Augustine reveals a true gem within Flagler College, an institution far exceeding its reputation as a premier Liberal Arts school. Established by the railroad tycoon Henry M. Flagler in 1888, the original structure served as the Hotel Ponce de Leon, a luxurious retreat for wealthy northerners during the winter months. Now, Flagler College stands as a testament to history and opulence, reflecting Flagler’s remarkable vision and making it a unique landmark unlike any other in the nation. Visitors can marvel at the stunning Spanish Renaissance architecture, a testament to Flagler’s influence, and immerse themselves in the campus’s rich heritage.
Dininig Hall
However, the dining hall will undoubtedly capture and hold your fascination; it houses 79 Louis Comfort Tiffany stained glass windows. These windows create a vibrant spectacle as sunlight filters through, showcasing what is believed to be the largest collection of its kind in a single location. The breathtaking beauty of these stained glass pieces highlights the extravagance of a bygone era, making it an unforgettable aspect of any visit to this St. Augustine highlight—a true hidden gem that is simply unmissable.
FAQs
What are the top 5 must-see hidden gems in St. Augustine?
The top 5 must-see hidden gems in St. Augustine include the Peña-Peck House’s secret garden, the hidden murals of Aviles Street, the secluded beach at Anastasia State Park, the mysterious artifacts at the Lightner Museum’s back rooms, and the tranquil trails of the Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve.
How do I access the secret garden at the Peña-Peck House?
The secret garden at the Peña-Peck House is accessible through the main house. It’s recommended to join one of the guided tours for detailed historical context and direct access to the garden.
Are the hidden murals of Aviles Street free to view?
Yes, the hidden murals of Aviles Street are free to view. This historic street offers a variety of vibrant murals tucked away in alleys and courtyards, making it a delightful exploration for art lovers.
What should I bring to the secluded beach at Anastasia State Park?
When visiting the secluded beach at Anastasia State Park, it’s advisable to bring sunscreen, water, snacks, and perhaps beach chairs or a blanket. Also, don’t forget to bring a camera to capture the stunning natural beauty of the area.
Can anyone visit the back rooms of the Lightner Museum to see the mysterious artifacts?
Access to the back rooms of the Lightner Museum may be restricted to special tours or events. It’s best to check the museum’s official website or contact them directly for information on how to participate in these exclusive tours.
What wildlife might I see at the Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve?
At the Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve, you might see a variety of wildlife, including birds like ospreys and pelicans, sea turtles, and possibly even dolphins along the coastline. Remember to keep a respectful distance from all wildlife to ensure their safety and yours.
Are there any fees involved in exploring these hidden gem?
Some hidden gems in St. Augustine, like certain areas of Anastasia State Park and the Lightner Museum, may have an admission fee. It’s advisable to check their official websites for the most current information on fees and opening hours.
